TroostplekThe internet resting place
J. Arch Getty

In memoriam · book of condolence

J. Arch Getty

also known as J. Arch Getty

Born
30 November 1950
Died
19 May 2025
Age
74 years
Resting places
Scientists & inventors Famous people, United States Countries

Biography

John Archibald Getty III (November 30, 1950 – May 19, 2025) was an American historian and professor at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), who specialized in the history of Russia and the history of the Soviet Union.

Life and career

Getty was born in Louisiana and grew up in Oklahoma. He received his Bachelor of Arts degree from the University of Pennsylvania in 1972 and his Ph.D. from Boston College in 1979. Getty was a professor at the University of California, Riverside, before he moved to UCLA.

Getty was a John Simon Guggenheim Fellow and a research fellow of the Russian State University for the Humanities (Moscow) and was senior fellow of the Harriman Institute (Columbia University) and the Davis Center (Harvard University). He was senior visiting scholar at the Russian Academy of Sciences in Moscow.

Getty died in Santa Monica, California on May 19, 2025, at the age of 74.

Research, ideas, and debates

Academic Sovietology after World War II and during the Cold War was dominated by the "totalitarian model" of the Soviet Union, stressing the absolute nature of Joseph Stalin's power. The "revisionist school" beginning in the 1960s focused on relatively autonomous institutions which might influence policy at the higher level. Matt Lenoe described the "revisionist school" as representing those who "insisted that the old image of the Soviet Union as a totalitarian state bent on world domination was oversimplified or just plain wrong. They tended to be interested in social history and to argue that the Communist Party leadership had had to adjust to social forces." Getty was one of a number of "revisionist school" historians who challenged the traditional approach to Soviet history, as outlined by political scientist Carl Joachim Friedrich, which stated that the Soviet Union was a totalitarian system, with the personality cult and almost unlimited powers of the "great leader" such as Stalin.

In Origins of the Great Purges, a book published in 1985, Getty said that the Soviet political system was not completely controlled from the center and that Stalin only responded to political events as they arose. The book was a challenge to works by Robert Conquest and part of the debates between the "totalitarian model" and "revisionist school" of the Soviet Union. In an appendix to the book, Getty also questioned the previously published findings that Stalin organized himself the murder of Sergey Kirov to justify his campaign of Great Purge. Getty saw Stalin's rule as dictatorial but not totalitarian because the latter demanded an administrative and technological effectiveness that did not exist.

The "totalitarian model" historians objected to the "revisionist school" of historians such as Getty as apologetics for Stalin and accused them of downplaying the terror. Lenoe responded that "Getty has not denied Stalin's ultimate responsibility for the Terror, nor is he an admirer of Stalin." During the debates in the 1980s, the use of émigré sources and the insistence on Stalin's engineering of Kirov's murder became embedded in the two sides' position. In a review of Conquest's work on the Soviet famine of 1932–1933, especially The Harvest of Sorrow, Getty wrote that while Stalin and the Soviet Politburo were primarily responsible, "there is plenty of blame to go around. It must be shared by the tens of thousands of activists and officials who carried out the policy and by the peasants who chose to slaughter animals, burn fields, and boycott cultivation in protest."

In a 1987 review for the London Review of Books (LRB) about Conquest's work, Getty wrote: "Conquest's hypothesis, sources and evidence are not new. Indeed, he himself first put forward his view two years ago in a work sponsored by the American Enterprise Institute. The intentional famine story, however, has been an article of faith for Ukrainian émigrés in the West since the Cold War. ... Conquest's book will thus give a certain academic credibility to a theory which has not been generally accepted by non-partisan scholars outside the circles of exiled nationalities. In today's conservative political climate, with its 'evil empire' discourse, I am sure that the book will be very popular." In the same LRB article, Getty gave his interpretation of the events, which is in line with the "revisionist school" bottom-up approach.

With the dissolution of the Soviet Union and the release of the Soviet archives, some of the heat has gone out of the debate, as "totalitarian model" and "revisionist" school merged into "postrevisionism" as a synthesis. Getty was one of the most active Western historians researching the archives along with Lynne Viola. A 1993 study of archival data by Getty et al. showed that a total of 1,053,829 people died in the Gulag from 1934 to 1953. In a 1993 study, Getty wrote that the opening of the Soviet archives has vindicated the lower estimates put forth by the "revisionist school" scholars. His analysis of Stalin as powerful but having at least in his early rule, to work within an array of competing interests and powers, a cruel but ordinary mortal being who was not omnipotent nor a master planner, has been described as a representation of the banal evil described by Hannah Arendt.

Source: Wikipedia, available under the licence CC BY-SA 4.0.

In Memoriam web link

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._Arch_Getty

Condolences and flowers 0

The book of condolence for J. Arch Getty: offer your condolences to the family below, lay a flower or light a candle.

  • TroostplekOur sympathy to all who are left behind.

Be the first to offer your condolences or lay a flower.

Your condolences or a flower

What would you like to place?
How long is your message?
Choose a flower

All 27

Wreaths 4

Funeral bouquets 3

Classic 20

How long should your flower stay?

Lay flowers more often? Become a member: lay as many flowers as you like, and they all stay forever. €6.00 a month or €60.00 a year. Become a member (with a free account)

0 / 500 characters

Troostplek is a place to remember. Messages are read first and then placed; messages that do not fit here are removed without explanation.

Let your flower stay foreverPost a longer condolence

€3.95€3.45 once

  • Your flower is laid now and can be seen straight away.
  • As soon as your payment has arrived, it stays forever.
  • If the payment does not go through, it stays for a month, like a free flower.
  • Your condolence is posted now. Until your payment has arrived, only the first 500 characters can be read.
  • As soon as your payment has arrived, the whole text can be read.
  • Rather free? Go back and make your message shorter than 501 characters.
How would you like to pay?

With crypto you pay the network's transaction costs yourself, on top of the amount. With iDEAL and a bank transfer there are no extra costs.

With a bank transfer or crypto you will see how to pay after placing it. Fill in your email address to also receive it by email.

Lay flowers more often? As a member you lay as many flowers as you like, forever, from €6.00 a month.Writing longer messages more often? As a member you write as much as you like, for free, from €6.00 per month. Become a member

Report

Does this message or flower not belong on Troostplek? After your report it is hidden until we have looked at it.

Report a mistake or addition

About the memorial of J. Arch Getty. Fill in what should be different; the rest may stay empty.

Now: J. Arch Getty

Now: 30 November 1950

Now: 19 May 2025

Now: Scientists & inventors